Where Have All the Italians Gone?
By Kiril Yurukov · · 4 min read

Serie A can still attract famous names, but while ageing stars continue to arrive, Italy’s own young players are struggling to find a place in their domestic league.
Serie A has rediscovered some of its international glamour, although in a very different form from the era when Italian clubs routinely signed the best players in the world at the peak of their careers. Luka Modrić remains at Milan at 41, Kevin De Bruyne is at Napoli at 35, John Stones has joined Inter at 32, while 34-year-old David Alaba is now joining Udinese as a free agent.
There is nothing inherently wrong with this strategy, because experienced players can still provide quality, leadership and international attention, while signing established names late in their careers can make financial sense for clubs unable to compete with Premier League spending power. The concern begins when this becomes part of a broader pattern in which Serie A continues finding room for experienced foreign players while struggling to create enough space for the next generation of Italians.
The numbers suggest that this is becoming a structural problem rather than simply an impression.
1. Italians are becoming a minority in their own league
In its 2026 analysis of the state of Italian football, the FIGC reported that players ineligible to represent Italy accounted for 67.9% of all Serie A minutes, compared with 48.3% in France and 39.6% in Spain. Among the 284 players averaging at least 30 minutes per match after 31 rounds, only 89 were Italian, and ten of those were goalkeepers.
The situation becomes even more striking when age is considered, because only 1.9% of Serie A minutes were played by Italian U21 footballers, placing the league 49th out of 50 competitions monitored by CIES for the FIGC report. Serie A also had an average player age of 27, making it the eighth-oldest league in Europe and older than the leading divisions in England, Germany, France, the Netherlands and Portugal.
This is not a new development either, because FIGC’s previous ReportCalcio showed that Italian U21 players received only 2.8% of Serie A minutes in 2022/23, while players developed by the clubs they represented accounted for just 5.6%, one of the lowest figures in European football.
The problem therefore goes considerably deeper than the nationality of a few high-profile transfers.
2. Italy is producing talent, but Serie A is not using enough of it
The obvious explanation would be that Italian football simply is not producing enough good young players, but the results of the national youth teams make that argument difficult to sustain.
Between 2013 and 2023, Italy reached 24 final tournaments across the U17, U19, U20 and U21 levels, more than any other European country during that period, while the U17 national team has since won the European Championship twice in three years, taking the title in both 2024 and 2026.
The contradiction is therefore difficult to ignore, Italy can develop competitive youth national teams, but many of those players struggle to accumulate meaningful first-team experience once they reach senior football.
FIGC data illustrates the size of that development gap particularly well. Italian U21 players competing across Serie A and the other four major European leagues had accumulated around 63,000 career minutes in first divisions by May 2024, compared with approximately 193,000 for French players of the same age and 88,000 for Spaniards. Their Champions League exposure was even more limited, with Italians recording only 422 minutes compared with roughly 5,000 for young Spanish, English and German players and almost 7,000 for French players.
Italy therefore appears to have less of a talent-production problem than a talent-transition problem.
3. The short-term logic creates a long-term problem
From an individual club’s perspective, the preference for experience is understandable because coaches and sporting directors are judged on immediate results, making an established 30-plus player with hundreds of elite matches appear less risky than giving significant responsibility to a 20-year-old who still needs time to develop.
Serie A’s financial position also encourages opportunism in the transfer market, where an experienced international available on favourable terms can offer immediate sporting and commercial value without requiring the transfer fees associated with elite players in their prime.
The problem emerges when individually rational decisions create a collectively damaging outcome. If most clubs prefer experience today, fewer young Italians accumulate the minutes necessary to become elite players tomorrow, which reduces the domestic talent pool available to Serie A and eventually leaves the national team choosing from an increasingly narrow group of players with genuine top-level experience.
Veterans such as Modrić, De Bruyne and Alaba are not the cause of Italian football’s development problem, and Serie A should continue attracting players capable of improving its quality and international profile. The real question is whether Italian clubs can create room for those names without blocking the pathway for the players who are supposed to define the league’s next decade.
Italy does not appear to have stopped producing talented footballers; increasingly, the problem is that Serie A is not giving enough of them the opportunity to become great ones.
Related Stories
More Than Friendlies, Why The Nations League Matters More Than Ever
The UEFA Nations League was created in 2018 largely to replace low-stakes international friendlies with competitive matches between countries of a similar level, but the competition has gradually developed into something more important within the European football calendar.
· 5 min read
The New Champions League, A Look At The UEFA’S New Format
UEFA’s new Champions League format has changed the weakest part of the competition by making the opening phase more unpredictable, giving smaller clubs a better chance to remain relevant and ensuring that league position matters almost until the final whistle.
· 4 min read
The Death Of The Number 10? When Football Started Controlling Creativity
Modern football has become more organised, more intense and more tactical. But has it also become less creative? There was a time when one of the most important questions in building a football team was simple, who is your number 10?
· 6 min read

